Pet Society Fish List

Here’s a running list of Fish and Bait which I’ve compiled, thanks to readers and friends. As you can see, there seems to be very little rhyme or reason to this. More expensive items do not necessarily lead to better fish. A whole pizza (120 coins) only hooked a little Starfish while a coconut half (10 coins) got an Altum Angelfish. A coconut half also yielded a broken bike wheel. Like so many things in Pet Society, luck plays a role.

Color Codes:
This color denotes either Pro Fishing Gear or Fish Biscuit is required.
This color means the fish was a cash item limited to a certain holiday.
Things left in white are free, i.e. cheapos like me can catch them!

Fish & Flotsam	Bait
African Butterflyfish	Choc-top, Halloween Candycane, Halloween Lolly from the trees.
Altum Angelfish	Baby Milk, Coconut Half, Corn
Amberstone Bug	Banana
Apple Fish	Apple
Banana Fish	Banana (either home-grown or store bought)
Bike Wheel	Coconut Half
Birthdaycake Fish	2000-coin Birthday Cake. However, there is no guarantee. You just might get a squid instead!
Biscuit Fish	Fish Biscuit from Cash Shop
Black Angelfish	Fish Biscuit (from Cash Shop)
Blackcap Gramma	Pro Fishing Gear
Black Ghost Knifefish	Rare Steak
Black Kittenfish (Halloween)	Halloween Fish Biscuit from Cash Shop These items are available until November 2, 2009
Blowfish	Apple, Homegrown Pet Drake, Pink Donut
Blue Betta	Fish Biscuit from the Cash shop
Blue Gill	Apple, Cheese, Mocha, Onion, Pear
Blue Girdled Angelfish	Pro Fishing Gear
Blue Ram	Cheese, Pink Donut
Blue Sea Urchin Shell	Lemon, Croissant
Broken Pot	Strawberry, Watermelon Slice
Butterflyfish	Fish Biscuit from Cash Shop
Cactus Fish	Choc-top, strawberry
Carp	Pear, Pineapple, Yellow Ribbon Cupcake
Catfish	Milk
Cheese Fish	Cheese (duh!)
Chestnut Fish	Mont Blanc Cake
Chocolate Donut Fish	Chocolate Donut
Chocolate Fish	Chocolate Heart
Clam with Pearl	Carrot, Samosa
Clownfish	Apple, Pineapple, Pink Donut, Strawberry Milk
Clown Knifefish	Apple
Clown Loach	Banana
Clown Triggerfish	Fish Biscuit (from Cash Shop)
Coconut Fish	Home-grown Coconut
Coelacanth	Pumpkin Cookie, plus Pro fishing gear (hat, vest, gloves)
Conch Shell	Pear, Pizza Slice, Watermelon
Coral	Mocha, Rare Steak
Crab	Blueberry Cupcake, Corn, Milk, Onion, Pineapple, Pear
Crowfish	Halloween Fish Biscuit from the Cash Shop
Crystalfish	Fish biscuit from the Cash Shop
Cubicus Boxfish	Pro Fishing Gear
Cupcake Fish	Home-grown Cupcake
Daifuku Mochifish	Fish Biscuit
Dogfish	Cheeseburger, Melon
Draculafish (Halloween)	Halloween Fish Biscuit from Cash Shop These items are available until November 2, 2009
Elephantnose Fish	Cheese, Coconut Juice, Home-grown Apple
Elfish	Holiday Fish Biscuit from Cash Shop (available until Dec 28, 2009).
Emperor Angelfish	Pro Fishing Gear
Empty Bottle	Courgette, Melon
Fish Bones	Broccoli, Pear, Popcorn, Watermelon
Flounder	Apple, Milk, Pink Donut, White Ribbon Cupcake
Flying Fish	A reader, Stefanie H. reports that she caught this with an apple. However, her pet was also wearing the Pro Fishing Clothes from Cash Shop (hat/jacket/glove).
Frontosa	Carrot, Pink Donut, Strawberry Milk
Gingerbreadfish	Holiday Fish Biscuit from Cash Shop (available until December 28, 2009).
Gold Starfish	Holiday Fish Biscuit from Cash Shop (available until December 28, 2009).
Golden Butterflyfish	Apple, Candy Corn, Carrot
Golden White Cloud	Bug Jello, Chocolate Donut, Homegrown Pet Drake, Lemon
Green Discus	Carrot, Corn, Donut
Green Gummifish	Fish Biscuit from Cash Shop
Green Neon Tetra	Choc-Top, Groovy Sandwich, Mini Festive Cake
Groovy Teddyfish	Groovy Sandwich
Guppy	Fish Biscuit from Cash Shop
Icefish	Hot Chocolate from Food Shop or any hot beverage from the Cafe (Mocha, Latte, Cappuccino, Espresso)
Jack O’Lanternfish	Halloween Cake, Home-grown Pumpkin
Jellyfish	Fish Biscuit (from the Cash Shop)
Kangaroofish	Choc-top
Lemonfish	Lemon, duh!
Lilac Starletfish	Fish Biscuit (from Cash Shop)
Lionfish	Fish Biscuit (from Cash Shop)
Longbill Spearfish	A reader caught this with a lemon, but she was also wearing the Pro fishing gloves, hat and vest.
Longnose Butterflyfish	Pro Fishing Gear
Lovefish	Apple, Pink Donut, Samosa
Loveroot Fish	Beetroot, Loveroot
Macaronfish	Birthday Cake (2000 coins), Carrot, Chocolate Donut, Lemon, Melon, Strawberry. Conclusion: Don’t waste your money on the Birthday Cake.
Masked Butterflyfish	One reader says that she caught this beauty using an apple. But she was also wearing the Pro fishing gear (hat, vest, gloves).
Message in a Bottle	Grapes, Lemon, Pear
Mola Mola	A reader says “This fish is HUGE! It takes up almost the entire space of a small aquarium!” She caught it with a watermelon slice, while wearing the Pro fishing gear.
Monsterfish (Halloween)	Halloween Fish Biscuit from Cash Shop These items are available until November 2, 2009
Mosquitofish	Pumpkin
Mummyfish (Halloween)	Halloween Fish Biscuit from Cash Shop These items are available until November 2, 2009
Octopus	Bone (100 coin white bone, not the 6 coin biscuit), Pear
Old Boot	Orange Juice
Orangefish	Home-grown Orange
Paddlefish	Apple, Blueberry Cupcake, Mocha, Pineapple, Yellow Ribbon Cupcake
Paradisefish	100-coin bone, Strawberry
Pink Heartfish	Apple, Onion, Pink Donut, Strawberry
Pink Ribbonfish	Fish Biscuit from the Cash Shop
Pink Starletfish	Fish Biscuit from the Cash Shop
Pink Seahorse	Fish Biscuit from the Cash Shop
Piranha	Rare Steak
Pretzelfish	Soft Pretzel
Puddingfish	Holiday Fish Biscuit from the Cash Shop (available until Dec 28, 2009).
Puppyfish	Bone (100 coin white bone)
Red Demekin Goldfish	Corn, Eyeball, Home-grown Orange, Strawberry
Red Salmon	Carrot, Pear
Romantic Icefish	Several people have claimed that you can catch this with anything. Yeah, right! We all know how luck plays a HUGE role in this game.
Rusted Anchor	Broccoli
Santa Hatfish	Holiday Fish Biscuit from Cash Shop (available until December 28, 2009).
Sardine	Celery, Chocolate Poo (the edible kind that used to be in the store), Corn, Home-grown Apple, Home-grown Cherry, Milk, Salami
Scary Clownfish	Halloween Fish Biscuit from the Cash Shop
Scary Maskfish (Halloween)	Halloween Fish Biscuit from Cash Shop These items are available until November 2, 2009
Schooling Banner Fish	Croissant
Sea Anemone	Watermelon
Sea Slug	Apple, Baklava
Sea Star Baby Doll	Melon, Pear, Pizza Slice, Onion, Strawberry Soft Serve
Sea Urchin	Apple, Bread, Cheese, Cheeseburger, Coconut Half, Pizza Slice
Seahorse	Carrot
Seaweed I don’t have an image of this, but really, does anyone care about seaweed?	Biscuit, Cauliflower
Sheepfish	Cauliflower, Pear
Shrimp	Coconut Half, Corn, Onion, Pineapple, Pizza Slice, Rare Steak
Silver Arowana	Blueberry Cupcake, Cheeseburger, Strawberry Soft Serve, Yellow Ribbon Cupcake
Spotted Bass	Cauliflower
Squid	Birthday Cake (2000 coins), Home-grown Apple, Home-grown Cupcake, Watermelon. Conclusion: Don’t waste your money on the Birthday Cake.
Star Fish	Bone, Chocolate Donut, Corn, Cupcake, Home-grown Apple, Pear, Pineapple, Sorbet Paradise, Whole Pizza
Strawberry Fish	Strawberry (duh!)
Strawberry Donut Fish	Pink Donut
Strawberry Shortcake Fish	Home-grown Strawberry Shortcake
Tancho Pearlscale	Fish Biscuit from the Cash Shop.
Teddyfish	Fish Biscuit from the Cash Shop. Home-grown Pet Drake also works, as confirmed by three readers.
Turkeyfish	Roast Turkey, Whole Pumpkin Pie
Vagabond Butterflyfish	Pro Fishing Gear
Watermelon Fish	Melon
Zebra Fish	Just kidding! No such thing. Just a test to see if you’ve read this far!

Via